Discovercars logo
#1
World's Most Visited Car Rental Comparison and Booking Website

Car Rental in Newburgh

Save up to 70%. Clear prices, no surprises.
Trusted by 10M travelers
24/7 Support
Free Cancellation
Desktop Image
Newburgh, USA - New York
Sat, Nov 21
Sun, Nov 29
Driver's country of residence is and age is
Rated Excellent
295,896 reviews on
1,000+ brands
1,000+ brands

Cheapest car rental rates

No deductible

Chevrolet Spark

or similar Economy
Automatic
4
A/C
4
1
$127.00
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Average
In terminal
Pick-up information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St
Drop-off information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Low deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
No deductible

Kia Soul

or similar Compact
Automatic
5
A/C
4
2
$95.13
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Average
In terminal
Pick-up information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St
Drop-off information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Low deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
No deductible

Toyota Corolla

or similar Intermediate
Automatic
5
A/C
4
3
$96.52
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Average
In terminal
Pick-up information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St
Drop-off information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Low deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
No deductible

Mazda CX-50

or similar Intermediate SUV
Automatic
5
A/C
5
4
$91.21
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Average
In terminal
Pick-up information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St
Drop-off information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Low deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
No deductible

Volkswagen Jetta

or similar Standard
Automatic
5
A/C
4
5
$97.67
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Average
In terminal
Pick-up information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St
Drop-off information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Low deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
No deductible

Toyota Camry

or similar Full-size
Automatic
5
A/C
4
6
$97.67
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Average
In terminal
Pick-up information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St
Drop-off information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Low deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
No deductible

Toyota RAV4

or similar Intermediate SUV
Automatic
5
A/C
4
7
$100.16
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Average
In terminal
Pick-up information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First Street, New Windsor, NY, 12553
The rental desk is located inside the terminal. Please follow the signs to car rental area.
Drop-off information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First Street, New Windsor, NY, 12553
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Average deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
No deductible

Kia Soul

or similar Compact
Automatic
5
A/C
4
8
$100.76
per day
Free cancellation
8.2
Good
In terminal
Pick-up information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St, New Windsor, NY, 12553
The rental desk is located inside the terminal. Please follow the signs to car rental area.
Drop-off information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St, New Windsor, NY, 12553
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Average deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
No deductible

Toyota Corolla

or similar Intermediate
Automatic
5
A/C
4
9
$103.15
per day
Free cancellation
8.2
Good
In terminal
Pick-up information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St, New Windsor, NY, 12553
The rental desk is located inside the terminal. Please follow the signs to car rental area.
Drop-off information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St, New Windsor, NY, 12553
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Average deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
No deductible

Toyota RAV4

or similar Intermediate SUV
Automatic
5
A/C
4
10
$103.35
per day
Free cancellation
8.2
Good
In terminal
Pick-up information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St, New Windsor, NY, 12553
The rental desk is located inside the terminal. Please follow the signs to car rental area.
Drop-off information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St, New Windsor, NY, 12553
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Average deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
No deductible

Toyota Camry

or similar Full-size
Automatic
5
A/C
4
11
$106.73
per day
Free cancellation
8.2
Good
In terminal
Pick-up information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St, New Windsor, NY, 12553
The rental desk is located inside the terminal. Please follow the signs to car rental area.
Drop-off information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St, New Windsor, NY, 12553
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Average deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
No deductible

Volkswagen Jetta

or similar Standard
Automatic
5
A/C
4
12
$106.73
per day
Free cancellation
8.2
Good
In terminal
Pick-up information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St, New Windsor, NY, 12553
The rental desk is located inside the terminal. Please follow the signs to car rental area.
Drop-off information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St, New Windsor, NY, 12553
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Average deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
No deductible

Mitsubishi Mirage

or similar Economy
Automatic
4
A/C
4
13
$136.21
per day
Free cancellation
8.2
Good
In terminal
Pick-up information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St, New Windsor, NY, 12553
The rental desk is located inside the terminal. Please follow the signs to car rental area.
Drop-off information
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
1130 First St, New Windsor, NY, 12553
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Average deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
Showing 9 out of 13 cars
The above prices are only approximate and were last updated at 11:31 on 18/11/26. Prices may vary based on the booking dates, length of rental, and car class.

Why book with us?

Special offers
Special offers
As a market leader, we get special offers like contactless pick-ups, great prices, and free upgrades.
Award-winning
Award-winning
World's Leading Car Rental Booking Website in the World Travel Tech Awards (4 years in a row).
Highly-rated
Highly-rated
A combined rating of 4.5 with 250k+ total reviews on platforms like Trustpilot, Google, and Review Center.
10M users
10M users
Have already booked on one of the fastest-growing car rental booking websites.

Travel information

Languages
English
Currency
USD
Drive on
Right-hand side
Country code
+1
Average car rental price
$63 per day
Average car rental length
5 days
Speed limit within town
40–72 km/h or 25–45 mph
Speed limit out of town
88–104 km/h or 55–65 mph
Acceptable limit of BAC
0.08%
Average gas price
$1.14 per liter or $4.31 per gallon
Lowest gas price
$0.83 per liter or $3.14 per gallon
Highest gas price
$1.19 per liter or $4.50 per gallon

Top 9 cities near Newburgh

  1. Long Islandfrom $53.10 per day
    83.9 km / 52.13 miles away
  2. New Yorkfrom $29.21 per day
    88.6 km / 55.05 miles away
  3. New Hartfordfrom $55.70 per day
    204.1 km / 126.82 miles away
  4. Syracusefrom $52.99 per day
    244.8 km / 152.11 miles away
  5. Rochesterfrom $53.10 per day
    351.3 km / 218.29 miles away
  6. Plattsburghfrom $53.10 per day
    358.3 km / 222.64 miles away
  7. Buffalofrom $53.43 per day
    429.3 km / 266.75 miles away
  8. Niagara Fallsfrom $60.71 per day
    451.1 km / 280.3 miles away
  9. Albanyfrom $53.65 per day
    1,431.9 km / 889.74 miles away

Map of top car rental locations

A
Stewart International Airport (SWF)
5 rental locations

When to book in Newburgh and for how long?

What is the cheapest month to rent a car in Newburgh?

Car rental prices in Newburgh vary by time of year. This graph shows the average prices per month to help you find the best time of year to rent.

Saver's insights

Cheapest monthSeptember Most expensive month December
Average price $40 A good deal $60 Cheapest supplier Budget Cheapest car type Large cars
Average rental costs per day in Newburgh
$144
$72
$0

$67

in January

Jan
Feb

$90

in March

Mar
Apr
May
Jun

$58

in July

Jul
Aug

$33

in September

Sep
Oct

$51

in November

Nov

$131

in December

Dec

The cheapest month to rent a car in Newburgh is September (when prices average $32.50 per day). This is 18% cheaper than the yearly average and 75% cheaper than renting in December (when prices average $131.18).

This information can help you identify the low season. But these are only average numbers. How much your car rental will cost will depend on the type of vehicle you rent, how long you’ll rent it for, and how far ahead you book. Simply enter your dates in the form at the top of the page to see the exact prices.

What's the most popular month to rent a car in Newburgh?

Based on the number of searches by our customers, the most popular month for renting a car in Newburgh is November, and the least popular is July.

Monthly searches in Newburgh by pick-up date relative to the average
2.4
1.2
0

1.1 times in January

Jan
Feb

1.1 times in March

Mar
Apr
May
Jun

0.5 times in July

Jul
Aug

0.5 times in September

Sep
Oct

2.2 times in November

Nov

0.5 times in December

Dec

What’s the usual rental length in Newburgh?

How long travelers keep their rental cars for varies from month to month: in July, the average renter keeps their car for 14 days, and in January, they keep their car for one day.

Average number of rental days in Newburgh
15
8
0

1 day in January

Jan
Feb

3 days in March

Mar
Apr
May
Jun

14 days in July

Jul
Aug

13 days in September

Sep
Oct

6 days in November

Nov

1 day in December

Dec

Car rental information

📍 Car rental locations1
✈️ Airport locations1
🔥 Popular suppliersAvis, Budget, National
🚗 Popular car typesSmall cars, SUVs, large cars
🤑 Lowest price$53 per day
👛 Cheapest supplierBudget

Frequently Asked Questions (updated: Nov 7, 2026)

Prices are lowest during September, starting at $33 for an Economy car and highest in December, when economy cars start at $131. Booking early for peak dates can save significantly. The most popular month in Newburgh is November, while the least popular month is July.
Newburgh hosts: Alamo, National, Enterprise, Avis, Budget. Rental cars tend to sell out in the summer months, so booking early is recommended.

Car rental statistics

Highest-rated company
Alamo (rated 8.7 / 10)
Lowest-rated company
Budget (rated 7.7 / 10)
Total rental companies
5
Average daily price
$63
Lowest daily price
$53
Total cars available
32

Top 5 suppliers in Newburgh in 2026

Alamo
1 location
Alamo
8.7
Very Good
Value for money
8.9
Ease of finding
8.2
Agent helpfulness
9.2
Pick-up speed
8.0
Drop-off speed
8.2
Car cleanliness
9.2
Car condition
9.1
$57–$502
per day
Most popular location
1130 1st St, New Windsor, NY 12553, United States
National
1 location
National
8.3
Good
Value for money
8.2
Ease of finding
8.2
Agent helpfulness
8.5
Pick-up speed
8.0
Drop-off speed
8.2
Car cleanliness
8.4
Car condition
8.5
$61–$506
per day
Most popular location
1130 1st St, New Windsor, NY 12553
Enterprise
1 location
Enterprise
8.2
Good
Value for money
8.2
Ease of finding
8.2
Agent helpfulness
8.3
Pick-up speed
8.0
Drop-off speed
8.2
Car cleanliness
8.2
Car condition
8.4
$54–$486
per day
Most popular location
1130 1st St, New Windsor, NY 12553
Avis
1 location
Avis
8.2
Good
Value for money
8.0
Ease of finding
8.2
Agent helpfulness
8.3
Pick-up speed
8.0
Drop-off speed
8.2
Car cleanliness
8.4
Car condition
8.3
$59–$80
per day
Most popular location
1130 First St, New Windsor, NY, 12553
Budget
1 location
Budget
7.7
Average
1 rating
Value for money
7.3
Ease of finding
8.2
Agent helpfulness
6.8
Pick-up speed
8.0
Drop-off speed
8.2
Car cleanliness
7.6
Car condition
7.8
$53–$83
per day
Most popular location
1130 First Street, New Windsor, NY, 12553

Award-winning service

World Travel Tech Awards - World's Best Car Rental Booking Website 2026
World Travel Tech Awards - World's Best Car Rental Booking Website 2026
World Travel Tech Awards - World's Best Car Rental Booking App 2026
World Travel Tech Awards - World's Best Car Rental Booking App 2026
Magellan Travel Weekly Gold Winner 2025 badge
Magellan Awards Gold Winner 2025
FT log
FT 1000: Europe's Fastest Growing Companies - Top 300 Companies 2025
Uzakrota Travel Awards - World’s Leading Car Rental Website 2022
Uzakrota Travel Awards - World’s Leading Car Rental Website 2022
Travel & Hospitality Awards 2021
Travel & Hospitality Awards 2021
FT log
FT 1000: Europe's Fastest Growing Companies - Top 300 Companies 2021

Highly recommended by our customers

Easy company to deal with!
Booked a car at a fair price, but later had to cancel the whole trip. Easy cancellat...
Malcolm,
Nov 19, 2026
Smoothest car rental ever
"Smoothest car rental ever! Zero hassle, very competitive price, no upsells. Amazing...
Dr. K,
Nov 19, 2026
Mr. MA
Fast searching with many kind of cars and services
ZHEN MA,
Nov 19, 2026
Dear Maxwell K.,
Dear Maxwell K., I am writing to express my sincere gratitude for your prompt assist...
Sing fai Cheung,
Nov 19, 2026
Good communication and easy to deal with
Good communication and easy to deal with
Sheila Canlas,
Nov 19, 2026
Easy to use and great rates
Easy to use and great rates
Ramez AlTurk,
Nov 19, 2026
Very easy website to navigate
Very easy website to navigate
LAANET SVEN,
Nov 19, 2026
Free upgrade to newest RAV4
Free upgrade to newest RAV4. Good value for money. No difficulties.
Stef Jansen,
Nov 19, 2026
Easy car rental
On the ball company....car pick up 100%
Chris Saunders ,
Nov 19, 2026
Quick and easy drop off and pick up.
Quick and easy drop off and pick up.
m badiru,
Nov 19, 2026
Cool
Cool experience!
Marco Osmetti,
Nov 19, 2026
All the rules are clearly stated.
All the rules are clearly stated.
Des,
Nov 19, 2026
good site
Easy site to use
mr p goodwin ,
Nov 19, 2026
Booking Experince
best price - I strongly advice for best value car booking
Erkan Sonmez,
Nov 19, 2026
Discovercars are consistently reliable
Discovercars are excellent - carry a great range of car hire providers, excellent pr...
John Tormey,
Nov 19, 2026
Very good
Everything went perfectly
Huseyin Topcuoglu,
Nov 19, 2026
Rated 4.6 / 5 based on 295,896 reviews. Showing our favorite reviews.

Save even more with our mobile app

Find exclusive deals
Find the best deals on the map
Manage and view your booking on the go
Scan to download and book on your phone
A woman looking at her phone in a parking lotThe DiscoverCars.com app opened with the search results for a medium car at Lisbon Airport showing
Sign up for our newsletter

Sign up for our newsletter

Sign up to receive the best car rental deals in your inbox! No spam, just exclusive deals!
By providing your email address you agree to our