Car Rental in Bay Shore
Save up to 70%. Clear prices, no surprises.
Trusted by 7M travelers
24/7 Support
Free Cancellation
Cheapest car rental rates
Zero deductible
Kia Rio
or similar Economy
What does "or similar" mean?
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
Automatic
5
1
A/C
4
$76.84
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Good
Rental office
Pick-up information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Drop-off information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Low deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
Zero deductible
Kia Soul
or similar Compact
What does "or similar" mean?
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
Automatic
5
2
A/C
4
$76.98
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Good
Rental office
Pick-up information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Drop-off information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Low deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
Zero deductible
Toyota Corolla
or similar Intermediate
What does "or similar" mean?
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
Automatic
5
1
A/C
4
$37.56
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Good
Rental office
Pick-up information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Drop-off information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Low deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
Zero deductible
Ford Edge
or similar Standard SUV
What does "or similar" mean?
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
Automatic
5
3
A/C
4
$49.21
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Good
Rental office
Pick-up information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Drop-off information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Low deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
Zero deductible
Toyota Camry
or similar Full-size
What does "or similar" mean?
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
Automatic
5
2
A/C
4
$41.59
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Good
Rental office
Pick-up information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Drop-off information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Low deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
Zero deductible
Volkswagen Jetta
or similar Standard
What does "or similar" mean?
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
Automatic
5
2
A/C
4
$41.59
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Good
Rental office
Pick-up information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Drop-off information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Low deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
Zero deductible
Jeep Grand Cherokee
or similar Standard Elite SUV
What does "or similar" mean?
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
Automatic
7
2
A/C
5
$59.29
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Good
Rental office
Pick-up information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Drop-off information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Low deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
Zero deductible
Toyota RAV4
or similar Intermediate SUV
What does "or similar" mean?
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
Automatic
5
3
A/C
4
$75.98
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Good
Rental office
Pick-up information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Drop-off information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Low deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
Zero deductible
Chrysler Pacifica
or similar Mini Van
What does "or similar" mean?
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
If the exact model isn’t available, you’ll get a car in the same category that’s the same size and has the same number of doors, transmission type, and features. This is standard for most car rental suppliers.
Automatic
7
4
A/C
4
$85.91
per day
Free cancellation
7.7
Good
Rental office
Pick-up information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Drop-off information
Bay Shore West
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Please clarify drop-off instructions with the supplier upon pick-up.
Low deposit
Instant confirmation!
Unlimited mileage
Pay now
The above prices are only approximate and were last updated at 20:45 on 16/03/26. Prices may vary based on the booking dates, length of rental, and car class.
Why book with us?
Special offers
As a market leader, we get special offers like contactless pick-ups, great prices, and free upgrades.
Award-winning
World's Leading Car Rental Booking Website in the World Travel Tech Awards (4 years in a row).
Highly-rated
A combined rating of 4.5 with 250k+ total reviews on platforms like Trustpilot, Google, and Review Center.
4M users
Have already booked on one of the fastest-growing car rental booking websites.
Table of contents
- Cheapest car rental rates
- Why book with us?
- Travel information
- Top 20 cities near Bay Shore
- Top 20 locations near Bay Shore
- Map of top car rental locations
- When to book in Bay Shore and for how long?
- Car rental information
- Most popular car models of rental suppliers
- Car rental statistics
- Top supplier in Bay Shore in 2026
- Award-winning service
Travel information
Languages
English
Currency
USD
Drive on
Right-hand side
Country code
+1
Average car rental price
$100 per day
Average car rental length
6 days
Speed limit within town
40–72 km/h
or
25–45 mph
Speed limit out of town
88–104 km/h
or
55–65 mph
Acceptable limit of BAC
0.08%
Top 20 cities near Bay Shore
- Huntingtonfrom $52.38 per day18.4 km / 11.43 miles away
- Lynbrookfrom $52.38 per day36.8 km / 22.87 miles away
- New Rochellefrom $52.38 per day49.7 km / 30.88 miles away
- Scarsdalefrom $52.20 per day55 km / 34.18 miles away
- White Plainsfrom $46.78 per day55.4 km / 34.42 miles away
- Long Island Cityfrom $52.38 per day59.3 km / 36.85 miles away
- Long Islandfrom $52.11 per day59.6 km / 37.03 miles away
- Yonkersfrom $55.40 per day59.6 km / 37.03 miles away
- Manhattanfrom $55.40 per day61.7 km / 38.34 miles away
- Brooklynfrom $55.13 per day62.8 km / 39.02 miles away
- New Yorkfrom $49.76 per day64.9 km / 40.33 miles away
- Southampton74.1 km / 46.04 miles away
- Staten Islandfrom $52.38 per day77.6 km / 48.22 miles away
- Spring Valleyfrom $52.58 per day79.7 km / 49.52 miles away
- Newburghfrom $52.38 per day107.7 km / 66.92 miles away
- Poughkeepsiefrom $52.38 per day122.3 km / 75.99 miles away
- Middletownfrom $52.38 per day124.4 km / 77.3 miles away
- Port Jervis141.3 km / 87.8 miles away
- Binghamtonfrom $47.81 per day270.2 km / 167.89 miles away
- New Hartford311.5 km / 193.56 miles away
Top 20 locations near Bay Shore
- Bay Shore Westfrom $52.58 per day2.1 km / 1.3 miles away
- Long Island MacArthur Airportfrom $52.11 per day14.4 km / 8.95 miles away
- Huntington Downtownfrom $52.38 per day18.4 km / 11.43 miles away
- Lynbrook Downtownfrom $52.38 per day36.8 km / 22.87 miles away
- New York International Airport Kennedyfrom $49.76 per day45.8 km / 28.46 miles away
- New Rochelle Downtownfrom $52.38 per day49.7 km / 30.88 miles away
- New York International Airport LaGuardiafrom $49.76 per day53.2 km / 33.06 miles away
- Westchester Airportfrom $52.11 per day54.3 km / 33.74 miles away
- White Plains Downtownfrom $46.78 per day55.4 km / 34.42 miles away
- Scarsdale Cityfrom $52.20 per day55.6 km / 34.55 miles away
- Brooklyn East Williamsburg57.5 km / 35.73 miles away
- Long Island City Downtownfrom $52.38 per day59.3 km / 36.85 miles away
- Yonkers Downtownfrom $55.40 per day59.6 km / 37.03 miles away
- Long Island downtown59.6 km / 37.03 miles away
- New York Yorkvillefrom $56.02 per day59.6 km / 37.03 miles away
- Brooklyn Williamsburgfrom $57.01 per day59.8 km / 37.16 miles away
- Manhattan Lenox Hillfrom $57.01 per day60.5 km / 37.59 miles away
- Brooklyn Prospect Heightsfrom $110.53 per day61.2 km / 38.03 miles away
- New York Midtown Eastfrom $64.21 per day61.3 km / 38.09 miles away
- Manhattan Valleyfrom $57.01 per day61.4 km / 38.15 miles away
Map of top car rental locations
A
Bay Shore West
1 rental locations
When to book in Bay Shore and for how long?
What is the cheapest month to rent a car in Bay Shore?
Car rental prices in Bay Shore vary by time of year. This graph shows the average prices per month to help you find the best time of year to rent.
Saver's insights
| Cheapest monthSeptember | Most expensive month December | |
| A good deal $78 | Cheapest supplier Budget | Cheapest car type Large cars |
Average rental costs per day in Bay Shore
$124
$62
$0
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
$28
in September
Sep
$53
in October
Oct
Nov
$113
in December
Dec
The cheapest month to rent a car in Bay Shore is September (when prices average $27.76 per day). This is 60% cheaper than the yearly average and 75% cheaper than renting in December (when prices average $112.68).
This information can help you identify the low season. But these are only average numbers. How much your car rental will cost will depend on the type of vehicle you rent, how long you’ll rent it for, and how far ahead you book. Simply enter your dates in the form at the top of the page to see the exact prices.
What's the most popular month to rent a car in Bay Shore?
Based on the number of searches by our customers, the most popular month for renting a car in Bay Shore is October, and the least popular is September.
Monthly searches in Bay Shore by pick-up date relative to the average
1.7
0.8
0
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
0.8 times in September
Sep
1.5 times in October
Oct
Nov
0.8 times in December
Dec
What’s the usual rental length in Bay Shore?
How long travelers keep their rental cars for varies from month to month: in September, the average renter keeps their car for 7 days, and in December, they keep their car for 3 days.
Average number of rental days in Bay Shore
8
4
0
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
7 days in September
Sep
6 days in October
Oct
Nov
3 days in December
Dec
Car rental information
| 📍 Car rental locations | 1 |
| 🔥 Popular suppliers | Budget |
| 🚗 Popular car types | SUVs |
| 🤑 Lowest price | $53 per day |
| 👛 Cheapest supplier | Budget |
Most popular car models of rental suppliers
| Rental Supplier | Model | Doors | Luggage | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Budget | Ford Edge | 4 | 3 | SUV |
| Budget | Chevrolet Suburban | 4 | 4 | SUV |
Car rental statistics
Total rental companies
1
Average daily price
$100
Lowest daily price
$53
Total cars available
9
Top supplier in Bay Shore in 2026
Budget
1 location
7.7
Good
Value for money
7.4
Ease of finding
8.2
Agent helpfulness
6.8
Pick-up speed
8.0
Drop-off speed
8.2
Car cleanliness
7.7
Car condition
7.8
$53–$137
per day
Most popular location
969 Sunrise Hwy N Service Rd,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States
Award-winning service
World Travel Tech Awards - World's Best Car Rental Booking Website 2025
World Travel Tech Awards - World's Best Car Rental Booking App 2025
Magellan Awards Gold Winner 2025
FT 1000: Europe's Fastest Growing Companies - Top 300 Companies 2025
Uzakrota Travel Awards - World’s Leading Car Rental Website 2022
Travel & Hospitality Awards 2021
FT 1000: Europe's Fastest Growing Companies - Top 300 Companies 2021
Highly recommended by our customers
Rated 4.6 / 5 based on 259,575 reviews. Showing our favorite reviews.
Save even more with our mobile app
Find exclusive deals
Find the best deals on the map
Manage and view your booking on the go
Scan the code on your phone to download
Sign up for our newsletter
Sign up to receive the best car rental deals in your inbox! No spam, just exclusive deals!
By providing your email address you agree to our
