Car Rental on Coney Island
- Search, Compare, and Save up to 70%!
✓ No Hidden Costs ✓ 24/7 Support ✓ Free Cancellation
700+ Trusted Suppliers:
Cheapest car rental rates
Compact
Hyundai Accent or similar
$60.83 per day
Intermediate
Volkswagen Jetta or similar
$61.26 per day
Economy
Kia Rio or similar
$65.24 per day
Standard
Volkswagen Passat or similar
$74.42 per day
Most popular car rental deals
Full-size
Toyota Camry or similar
$74.91 per day
Intermediate SUV
Toyota RAV4 or similar
$77.50 per day
Compact SUV
Nissan Kicks or similar
$91.06 per day
The above prices are only approximate and were last updated at 11:39 PM on 5/9/25. Prices may vary based on the booking dates, length of rental, and car class.
Why book with us?
Special offers
As a market leader, we get special offers like contactless pick-ups, great prices, and free upgrades.
Award-winning
World's Leading Car Rental Booking Website in the World Travel Tech Awards (4 years in a row).
Highly-rated
A combined rating of 4.5 with 200k+ total reviews on platforms like Trustpilot, Google, and Review Center.
4M users
Have already booked on one of the fastest-growing car rental booking websites.
Travel information
Languages
English
Currency
USD
Drive on
Right-hand side
Country code
+1
Average car rental price
$72 per day
Average car rental length
9 days
Speed limit within town
40 - 72 km/h or 25 - 45 mph
Speed limit out of town
88 - 104 km/h or 55 - 65 mph
Acceptable limit of BAC
0.08%
Average gas price
$0.93 per liter or $3.52 per gallon
Lowest gas price
$0.79 per liter or $2.99 per gallon
Highest gas price
$1.06 per liter or $4.01 per gallon
Top 11 locations near Brooklyn Coney Island
-
18.7 km / 11.6 miles away
-
24.1 km / 15 miles away
-
59.6 km / 37 miles away
-
78.2 km / 48.6 miles away
-
102.9 km / 63.9 miles away
-
242 km / 150.4 miles away
-
332.8 km / 206.8 miles away
-
417.2 km / 259.2 miles away
-
455.1 km / 282.8 miles away
-
473.4 km / 294.2 miles away
-
498 km / 309.4 miles away
Map of car rental locations
When are car rental prices the lowest on Coney Island?
The cost of renting a car on Coney Island varies by season. The table and graph below can help you find the best time of year to save on a rental car.
Average rental costs per day on Coney Island
The cheapest month of the year to rent a car on Coney Island is January — when rental costs average $33.75 per day. This is 37% cheaper than the yearly average and 61% cheaper than renting a car in November (when prices average $86.02 per day).
This information can help you identify the low season. But these are only average numbers. How much your car rental will cost will depend on the type of vehicle you rent, how long you’ll rent it for, and how far ahead you book. Simply enter your dates in the form at the top of the page to see the exact prices.
This information can help you identify the low season. But these are only average numbers. How much your car rental will cost will depend on the type of vehicle you rent, how long you’ll rent it for, and how far ahead you book. Simply enter your dates in the form at the top of the page to see the exact prices.
For how long do renters keep their vehicles on Coney Island?
How long travelers keep their rental cars varies by the time of year: in April the average rental period is 17 days, while in October, the average rental period is only 4 days.
Average number of rental days on Coney Island
What is the most popular time of year to rent a car on Coney Island?
Based on how many users search for a car in on Coney Island, travelers are most likely to rent a car in April, while they are least likely to rent in in December.
Monthly searches on Coney Island by pick-up date relative to the average
Car rental information
| Popular suppliers | Ace Rent a car |
| Popular car categories | Medium cars, Small cars, SUVs, Large cars |
| Lowest price | $61 per day |
| Cheapest supplier | Ace Rent a car |
Most popular car models of rental suppliers
| Rental Supplier | Model | Doors | Luggage | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ace Rent a car | Kia Rio | 4 | 1 | Small cars |
| Ace Rent a car | Hyundai Accent | 4 | 2 | Medium cars |
| Ace Rent a car | Toyota RAV4 | 5 | 2 | SUVs |
| Ace Rent a car | Hyundai Accent | 4 | 1 | Medium cars |
| Ace Rent a car | Toyota Camry | 4 | 2 | Large cars |
| Ace Rent a car | Dodge Durango | 5 | 3 | SUVs |
| Ace Rent a car | Toyota Rav4 | 4 | 2 | SUVs |
| Ace Rent a car | Chevrolet Express | 4 | 4 | Vans |
| Ace Rent a car | Chrysler Pacifica | 4 | 4 | Vans |
| Ace Rent a car | Volkswagen Jetta | 4 | 2 | Large cars |
Car rental statistics
Total rental companies
1
Average daily price
$72.17
Lowest daily price
$60.83
Total cars available
16
Top supplier on Coney Island in 2025
+18555500008
3221 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY, 11235
$61 - $96
Working hours
Mon:
08:00 - 19:00
Tue:
08:00 - 19:00
Wed:
08:00 - 19:00
Thu:
08:00 - 19:00
Fri:
08:00 - 19:00
Sat:
08:00 - 19:00
Sun:
08:00 - 19:00
Awards
World Travel Tech Awards - World's Best Car Rental Booking Website 2023
World Travel Tech Awards - World's Best Car Rental Booking App 2023
Magellan Awards Gold Winner 2023
Travel & Hospitality Awards 2021
FT 1000: Europe's Fastest Growing Companies - Top 300 Companies 2021
FT 1000: Europe's Fastest Growing Companies - Top 100 Companies 2020
Uzakrota Travel Awards - World’s Leading Car Rental Website 2022
Trustpilot - Top 10 Car Rental Agencies
SimilarWeb - Top 50 Car Rental Websites
Highly recommended by our customers
Download Our App
Book and manage your booking on the go
